3400 Westgate Drive
Durham, NC 27707
(800) 918-3985
Open 11AM to 12AM today
Live chat
(800) 918-3985
My orders My wish lists My profile My events
Sign in New account
Sign out
My orders My wish lists My profile My events
Sign in New account
Sign out
Signed in as
0 items 0
Trade in
Gift cards
Shopping cart 0
Card singles All Card singles Buy list Comic books
Games Graphic novels Toys
Card singles All Card singles Buy list Comic books
Games Graphic novels Toys
  • Games
    Board & card games Collectible card games Role-playing games Miniatures games Paints & modeling supplies Dice, tokens & mats
    Collectible card games
    Sealed packs & boxes Sleeves & storage
    Card singles
    Magic singles Magic buy list
  • Comics
    Comic book subscriptions Graphic novels Active titles Upcoming new titles Back-issues Issues by week Comics supplies
  • CCGs
    Collectible card games
    Sealed packs & boxes Sleeves & storage
    Card singles
    Magic singles Magic buy list
  • Toys
  • MoreCategories
    Games
    Board & card games Collectible card games Role-playing games Miniatures games Paints & modeling supplies Dice, tokens & mats
    Collectible card games
    Sealed packs & boxes Sleeves & storage
    Card singles
    Magic singles Magic buy list
    Comics
    Comic book subscriptions Graphic novels Active titles Upcoming new titles Back-issues Issues by week Comics supplies
    Other merchandise
    Gift cards
    Toys & statues
    Apparel Novelties Posters & art
    Brick & mortar store
    Location Hours Events Beers on tap Forum
  • Gift cards
  • Help & FAQs
  • Sign in
  • Account
    My orders My wish lists My profile My events
    Sign in New account
    Sign out
    Signed in as
  • 0 items 0
    Trade in
  • Brick & mortar store
    Location Hours Events Beers on tap Forum
  • Events
You have an inactive comic book subscription. Click here to activate.
You have started a singles trade-in. It currently has 0 items with a credit total of $.00. Click here to submit.
  • View options
  • Show filters
  • Filter by set
  • Showing cards from all sets
  • Filter by rarity
  • Filter by color
  • Filter by type
  • Other filters
close
Applied filters
Type Any: Creature - Nightmare
Clear all filters
1-50 of 104 results

Ashiok's Skulker

A common Creature - Nightmare from War of the Spark

SP/NM - $0.10
[FOIL] Ashiok's Skulker

A common Creature - Nightmare from War of the Spark

Out of stock
Banehound

A common Creature - Nightmare Hound from War of the Spark

SP/NM - $0.10
[FOIL] Banehound

A common Creature - Nightmare Hound from War of the Spark

Out of stock
[FOIL] Carnival Hellsteed (Pre-Release Stamped (Alternate Art))

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Return to Ravnica

SP/NM - $0.30
Carnival Hellsteed

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Ravnica Allegiance Guild Kits

SP/NM - $0.30
Qty: 1
Carnival Hellsteed

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Return to Ravnica

SP/NM - $0.30
[FOIL] Carnival Hellsteed

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Return to Ravnica

SP/NM - $0.30
Dread Presence

A rare Creature - Nightmare from Core Set 2020

SP/NM - $0.69
Qty: 1
[FOIL] Faceless Butcher

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from PDS: Graveborn

Out of stock
Faceless Butcher

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Time Spiral "Timeshifted"

Out of stock
[FOIL] Faceless Butcher

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Time Spiral "Timeshifted"

Out of stock
Faceless Butcher

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

Out of stock
Faceless Devourer

An uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horror from Time Spiral

SP/NM - $0.20
[FOIL] Faceless Devourer

An uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horror from Time Spiral

SP/NM - $0.20
Qty: 1
Gravegouger

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

SP/NM - $0.10
Hypnox

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

[FOIL] Hypnox

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

Out of stock
[FOIL] Laquatus's Champion (Pre-Release Stamped (Russian))

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

SP/NM - $2.19
Laquatus's Champion

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

[FOIL] Laquatus's Champion

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

SP/NM - $3.89
Qty: 1
Laquatus's Champion

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horror from Masters 25

SP/NM - $0.30
Leyline Prowler

An uncommon Creature - Nightmare Beast from War of the Spark

SP/NM - $0.20
[FOIL] Leyline Prowler

An uncommon Creature - Nightmare Beast from War of the Spark

Out of stock
Mesmeric Fiend

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Sorin vs. Tibalt

Out of stock
Mesmeric Fiend

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

Out of stock
[FOIL] Mesmeric Fiend

A common Creature - Nightmare Horror from Torment

Out of stock
Mesmeric Fiend

An uncommon Creature - Nightmare Horror from Masters 25

SP/NM - $0.20
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Welcome Deck 2016

SP/NM - $0.30
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Welcome 2017

Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Alpha

Out of stock
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Beta

Out of stock
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Unlimited Edition

Out of stock
Nightmare (Not Tournament Legal)

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Collector's Edition

Out of stock
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Revised Edition

Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from 4th Edition

Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from 5th Edition

SP/NM - $0.69
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Magic 2010

SP/NM - $0.30
[FOIL] Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Magic 2010

SP/NM - $0.39
Nightmare

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Magic 2014

Nightmare (Japanese)

A rare Creature - Nightmare Horse from Magic 2014

Out of stock
1-50 of 104 results

  • Your account
  • Your orders
  • Your subscription
  • Wish lists
  • Gift cards
  • Help
  • Contact Us
  • Payment & shipping
  • Returns
  • Privacy & security
  • Brick & Mortar
  • Store location
  • Hours
  • Events
  • Forums
  • Magic card singles
  • Browse cards
  • Browse buy list
  • FAQ: Card grades
  • FAQ: Selling your cards
© 2017 Atomic Empire